Monday, September 04, 2006

What was the point, really?

Yes, before you misinterpret my drift here, I do think it is unfortunate that Steve Irwin, the crocodile hunter Downunder bloke, was killed at the untimely and relatively tender age of 44. Ironically, his life was taken by a creature that is deemed relatively non-threatening when compared with such things as saltwater crocs and Komodo Dragons -- a benevolent stingray.

Yes, rays do pack a nasty barb, but they are not aggressive or threatening. I've swum with them, and the only caveat is to not step on that nasty barb -- or, obviously, to not have it driven into your chest.

When you think of all the ways that 'bonza bloke' could have died, well, crikey, it boggles the mind. So, going out in this way somehow indicates that the gods not only have a sense-of-humor, they are not to be trifled with when marauding their creatures.

My problem with the Steve Irwins (and again, I am not making light of his sad death) and others of his ilk is that they capitalize on the primal fears and prejudices of human beings. There are big, bad animals out there, seems to be the message. "They are to be feared, but I am a very brave dude and I laugh at danger, so I shall go out and taunt them just as an entertainment for you. I will poke them and prod them and really piss them off, just like a naughty kid will tease a kitten or puppy. And, because you would soil yourself if you actually ran into one of them in the wild, I am going to show you how brave I am."

The message, to me at least, seems to be, that our big predators are fair-game, in a figurative sense at least. While nouveau-sensitivity has deemed it tacky to go and take down a cape buffalo with a big gun, it is OK to show our mettle by challenging these unfortunate creatures in other ways. This odd practice is even more effective as an entertainment because crocodiles, water buffalo, sharks, lions and tigers and bears (oh my) really are dangerous, so there is always the off-chance there could be a mauling right before your very eyes as you sit there glued to the wide screen in your den.

I see it as the 'Jaws Syndrome'. Prior to that overstated Spielberg pic most people didn't have much of an opinion one way or another about Great White Sharks. And then, thanks to the perceived scariness of a mechanical contrivance, Great Whites became arch-villains for a few years and nobody wanted to go swimming in the same ocean wherein the carcharodon carcharias resided and stalked his prey. And, Great Whites were hunted and harassed, and author Peter Benchley ultimately became distressed because his adventure tale had vilified and creature that was ultimately innocent. Not innocent of being a vicious predator, but innocent of being malevolent about going about its business.

The great predators of this planet do what they do because that is what they are programmed to do. Crocodiles or sharks don't kill people because they hate them, they do it because they have no choice -- unlike us, I might add. A few weeks ago at a campsite about 100 miles north of here, a cougar chomped down on a little boy's head. The boys father heard his anguished cries and rushed out and gave the big cat the sort of shitkicking one can only give when one's nearest or dearest are threatened. The cat ran off into the woods, and the little boy was frightened and a bit scratched, but otherwise OK. Again, though, the cougar did not do as it did because it was a terrible creature; it did it because t was a cougar, and that is what cougars do. They eat smaller prey. And that smaller prey can be a fawn, a lamb, a piglet, a dog, or a little boy, as the case may be. That is the way it is.

I attest that our predators, in being the way they are, are undeserving of both bad-press and fear mongering. And in that, the Steve Irwins of the world, may he rest in peace, do nobody any great service. If you want to be frightened, just look at what our fellow humans do, and maybe do what you can to address that reality. There you might be able to do a bit of good, and not harass the crocodiles in the bargain.

9 Comments:

Blogger heiresschild said...

i smiled as i read this, thinking about other people's thoughts and reactions. even went "whoa" once or twice. there's a scripture that says "preach in season and out of season." that means when it's accepted by some and not accepted by others, but do it anyway. one of the things i like about you being a journalist is that you write in season and out of season, meaning what you write might be accepted by some and not accepted by others. but you write from the heart, and i like that. this is definitely food for thought. good points made.

sylvia

12:56 PM  
Blogger Jo said...

A couple of years ago Irwin took his one-month old newborn son into a crocodile den and held him with one hand while he fed a crocodile with the other hand. The crocodile could easily have thought, “Oh, yum, you’ve brought me something live to eat.” Irwin was exonerated for doing that, and his even wife said it was “exciting” for their son, as if a one-month old newborn is cognizant of being in the presence of a dangerous crocodile.

I don’t even trust strange dogs that I pass on the street. Animals are guided by instinct and people anthropomorphize them too much.

Unfortunately, Steve Irwin paid the ultimate price for taking too many risks. And it was just a matter of "when" rather than "if".

2:24 PM  
Blogger djn said...

I understand where you're coming from completely. My daughters and I used to watch the Crocodile Hunter every Saturday morning -- I thought he was so over-the-top, but fun. My girls loved him. You're right, it is sad, but you're also right that we should keep our respectful distance. May Steve rest in peace and hugs to Terri & their little ones, who will miss their dad's presence.

6:50 PM  
Blogger Wendy C. said...

I just feel sad about it, but I know my Dad is standing in the greeting line waiting to shake his hand and say "Crikey!" (Dad loved Steve Irwin, he watched his show with my kids all the time - good memories indeed...

Ian - I am writing a story, you can find it here (but please be gentle :-)
http://wendolawrites.blogspot.com/

Also, I have moved Hola to
http://holawendola.blogspot.com

I just needed a change, and a roadtrip was out of the question.

Still Your friend,
Wendy

6:54 PM  
Blogger rama said...

Hullo, very happy to discover this blog, and begin with this reflection of yours. Thanks. I look forward to svouring the contents of your archive. Best, rama

11:31 PM  
Blogger Hageltoast said...

for once i disagree with you, i feel that Irwins show demonstrated that although these animals are dangerous and to be respected, they are magnificent and beautiful and funnily enough it isn't their sole purpose to seek us out and kill us horribly. I learnt a lot from his shows and didn't really see him so much as being brave as just knowing what he was doing.
Mostly tho I feel sorry for his kids, he and his wife knew there were always risks in his line of work, his kids have lost their father.

12:28 AM  
Blogger AlieMalie said...

i think you're totally right, Ian.

it's very sad that he's gone, especially given that he did tons with regards to conservation and such ... but like you said, the gods DO have a sense of humour and, well, they're not afraid to let us have a taste of it every now and then.

:)
AM

10:19 AM  
Blogger heiresschild said...

i know this is yesterday's post, but i just wanted to come back for a few more comments. ian, you really did bring out some good points, and if i hadn't seen the comments from pennys from heaven, i might have thought differently. but i know her and respect and value her views greatly.

even today, i was thinking about your article. it's so true, wild animals are just that--wild. they do what they know to do to protect themselves and their families and to get food.

i was very upset and saddened by steve irwin's death, and am even more so today. i didn't watch his show, though i've watched him on the tonight show with jay leno many times. i feel very sad that a very vibrant person who loved life, loved what he did, and believed in what he did is no longer here by a fluke. i'm saddened that his wife and two young children will no longer have their husband and dad in their life.

i'm sure there'll be more "steve irwins," but i hope nothing like this happens again.

sylvia
tuesday, sept. 5, 2006

3:48 PM  
Blogger Dr. Deb said...

He has what we call a T-personality. Thrill seeking personality type. It is tragic how he died, but maybe something can be learned from his untimely death.

6:14 PM  

Post a Comment

Subscribe to Post Comments [Atom]

<< Home