Wednesday, August 30, 2006

What then do you think?

I see creepy Mark Karr is off the hook on the JonBenet Ramsey matter. Was there ever any doubt? Karr, who has already been convicted on child pornography charges, and has stated his fascination with young girls, including an intrigue with the murder of little JonBenet of Boulder Colorado back in 1996, seemed made-to-order and a perfect candidate for a rush-to-judgment.

But, he seems, rather than being a child-slayer, just another weird false-confessor. And, while false confession seems like a bizarre manifestation emanating from certain warped psyches, it is more common than we might think. As an example, in the case of the kidnapping of the Lindbergh baby in the 1930s, nearly 200 people confessed to committing the crime. In the notorious ‘Black Dahlia’ case in Los Angeles in the 1940s (never solved, but soon to featured in a new film in a theatre near you), over 30 people confessed to having killed her.

Reasons for false-confession can be manifold. Surely there is grandstanding – a momentary bite of publicity for people of remarkably little accomplishment. Better to be remembered for something, even if it’s something bad, goes their warped logic. It’s a morbid wish to be a celebrity at any cost. Currently this is known as the Paris Hilton Syndrome. Just kidding – sort of.

Another motivation, according to psychoanalysts, is a subconscious psychological need to be punished for something the individual actually wants to do, but has never actually done. Mark Karr is, I think, a dangerous dude, and it is quite within the realm of his fantasies that he could kill a little girl.

Whatever really happened to little JonBenet will likely never be solved; the entire investigation has been so thoroughly screwed up since day one, that there will probably be no resolution at this stage. Some suspect that aspects of the truth accompanied Patsy Ramsey to her grave a few months ago. Maybe so, but we’ll probably never know.

Whatever the case, I have my suspicions about the case. You likely have yours. Yours might be the same as mine.

The woods abound with unresolved issues. Life isn’t like CSI or Law & Order, wherein a transgression is solved and all wrapped up within a neat hour’s viewing. Real crime is much more like the often excellent series Cold Case, in which a tired, old and long-forgotten crime is suddenly resurrected and, like the other shows mentioned, neatly solved within the allotted time constrictions. Would that life were like that.

If life, and crime-solving were like that, we would know the truth about the OJ trial and the felon would be doing hard time.

I’m not saying OJ was the perp. But, I have my suspicions, and you have yours. Yours might be the same as mine.
Was Michael Jackson the pedophile he was accused of being in two high-profile trials? I cannot say. I have my suspicions. You have yours. Yours are possibly the same as mine.

Did the British Secret Service on a directive from the Royal Family bump off the beauteous Princess Diana? Was she a victim of Islamic terrorism directed at Dodi Fayed and his seeming concubine? I don’t know. You and I will likely never know. You and I are likely not meant to ever know. But I do have my suspicions. You have yours. Yours might be the same as mine.

In truth, an amazing number of nefarious doings are never solved. An old cop once told me that if you want to bump somebody off, and you cover your tracks well enough, you will likely not be apprehended. If you are apprehended and go to trial, you will likely not be convicted. If you are convicted, you will likely only do a fraction of the time you are sentenced to.

What’s that all about? I have my suspicions. You have yours. Yours just may be the same as mine.

8 Comments:

Blogger Dr. Deb said...

Hey Ian,
Great thoughts on this subject. I wrote a post about Factitious Disorder and Karr. I'll be putting it up on Friday. I think FD explains psychologically what goes on in high profile cases like this.

I've actually come across FD a few times in my career and it's chilling, to say the least.

******Spoiler Alert*****

Robin Williams' new movie "The Night Listener" deals with FD. It is a great, GREAT film. If you are so inclined, you can read the orginal true story by Amristad Maupin.

Ciao for now,
Deb

5:13 PM  
Blogger Deb Sistrunk Nelson said...

As the Mark Karr story unfolded, I found it very disturbing. I can't imagine what it's done to the Ramsey family.

Excellent post, and you got a good assist from Dr. Deb! :-)

6:32 AM  
Blogger djn said...

Hiya Ian!

Check out this site: http://www.co.boulder.co.us/da/dl/E-mails%20scanned.pdf

It contains the emails that John Karr wrote to the CU professor. It's long: 420 pages. I'd be curious to hear what you (and also Dr Deborah Serani) think of this material.

In my opinion, Karr is an incredibly dangerous person. The authorities better keep tabs on him...

9:16 AM  
Blogger Jo said...

Greetings from Chimney Lake. My little cabin is now in the 21st century. What a great post this is, and I just had to comment. When my daughter was seven years old one of her school chums was abducted and murdered. She was a sweet little girl. The police knew who did it but they did not have enough evidence to arrest him. The little girl’s parents were so distraught they moved to another country and the case went cold. Then Clifford Olsen went on his killing spree and I was afraid to let my daughter do anything on her own. It robbed her and other kids on the Lower Mainland of their independence.

Isn’t there some statute whereby this creepy Mark Karr can be charged with making a false confession, thereby keeping him locked up? I think his fantasy world has gone so far that if he were released he would act out his fantasy. “See, I told you I killed her.” It’s a terrifying thought.

10:40 AM  
Blogger Leslie: said...

Hi Josie! I thought we wouldn't hear from you for a week, but I guess you took your laptop with you. Hope you're having a grand time - restful and peaceful.

12:50 PM  
Blogger Ian Lidster said...

Dear Dr. Deb: I'll be looking forward to your posting tomorrow, and thank you for your thoughtful insights (as always) I also didn't realize such was the subject of 'The Night Listener'.

Dear Peg: Taking life in bite-sized chunks is the only way we can keep our sanity, I agree.

Dear Deb: I guess with the Ramsey family, they might have thought they would finally get some closure. No such luck.

Dear djn: I will check out the site you offer here. Of course, you kind of live front-and-center with all of this. Sometimes I think maybe it should just be let go. I completely agree that he is a dangerous person and probably a potential killer. Josie's observation on the matter matches yours.

Dear Josie:Yes, the infamous Olsen matter here in BC, and I remember you telling me once before about your fears for your daughter. Utterly understandable.
I also agree with you that there should be some means by which a creep like this should be locked up. But, as you and I know, the law is an ass, and you cannot jail somebody 'before the fact', even when the potential is huge. That doesn't do much to protect society, does it? Very nice to hear from you.

7:27 PM  
Blogger djn said...

Darn, it looks like they removed the emails from that site... It was very interesting... My step-sisters and I are true-crime investigators in our spare time. ;) Anytime we have a get-together, you can find the three of us in a corner somewhere talking about the current mysteries.

8:41 AM  
Blogger yanmaneee said...

bape hoodie
louboutin outlet
goyard bags
converse shoes
goyard
jordan 13
birkin bag
kobe basketball shoes
yeezys
coach outlet store

3:16 AM  

Post a Comment

Subscribe to Post Comments [Atom]

<< Home